After a prolonged court docket battle that lasted practically 4 years, a US appeals court docket this week lastly dominated in favour of Qualcomm towards the Federal Commerce Fee (FTC) over a case of unfair patent licensing practices. Because of this, Qualcomm would not be compelled to renegotiate their previous offers with clients.
The FTC filed a case towards Qualcomm Inc. for “unreasonably restraining commerce in, and unlawfully monopolizing” two communication applied sciences – CDMA and LTE. Qualcomm initially misplaced the case in Could 2019 after a case dominated in favour of the FTC, after which they appealed the choice with the Ninth Circuit Court docket of Appeals in July 2019.
The appeals court docket found that the FTC couldn’t “satisfactorily
clarify how Qualcomm’s alleged breach of its contractual
dedication itself impaired the alternatives of rivals”, lastly resulting in a call being dominated in favour of Qualcomm. If Qualcomm misplaced the enchantment, they must renegotiate offers made with older clients, which may have been an enormous blow to Qualcomm’s place within the business.
Commenting on the ultimate verdict, Don Rosenberg, Government Vice President and Common Counsel of Qualcomm Inc. mentioned:
The Court docket of Appeals unanimous reversal, totally vacating the district court docket determination, validates our enterprise mannequin and patent licensing program and underscores the great contributions that Qualcomm has made to the business. We thank the panel for its considerate consideration of this vital case.